The argument to arm teaches, increase the use of resource offices and harden HSs seems to run counter to 2nd A advocates because it is doing exactly what they fear the most ..... an increasingly armed state apparatus.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Miscellaneous And Off Topic Subjects
Collapse
X
-
Arming teachers is just silly.
At the schools where they have an actual real, legitimate threat of gun violence, they have metal detectors and guards. That's quite the expenditure, but for some schools the threat is real enough to make it worthwhile.
Seeing as how you're not taking 300 million guns out of circulation nor stopping criminals from getting guns (a War on Guns! would go about as well as our War on Drugs!), if you really want to stop school shootings this would an effective approach, at least of areas inside the school.
That said, the shooters can still wait outside. Or go to other public places.
The reality that no one probably wants to accept is that these are going to continue a limited, random-type pace and there really isn't any law, action or otherwise that's going to change it. And if they actually pass some of these things -- whether it's arm teaches or ban AR15s, they'll still happen and the reaction won't be, "welp, maybe we can't do much about them" -- the reaction will be "we didn't arm and train the teachers well enough! or we didn't ban enough guns!Dan Patrick: What was your reaction to [Urban Meyer being hired]?
Brady Hoke: You know.....not....good.
- Top
Comment
-
"The problem with quotes on the Internet is that it is sometimes hard to verify their authenticity." -Abraham Lincoln
- Top
Comment
-
Great find, AA. There are better scenes, but watching that scene was the first time I knew I was watching greatness.Dan Patrick: What was your reaction to [Urban Meyer being hired]?
Brady Hoke: You know.....not....good.
- Top
Comment
-
Originally posted by iam416 View PostArming teachers is just silly.
At the schools where they have an actual real, legitimate threat of gun violence, they have metal detectors and guards. That's quite the expenditure, but for some schools the threat is real enough to make it worthwhile.
Seeing as how you're not taking 300 million guns out of circulation nor stopping criminals from getting guns (a War on Guns! would go about as well as our War on Drugs!), if you really want to stop school shootings this would an effective approach, at least of areas inside the school.
That said, the shooters can still wait outside. Or go to other public places.
The reality that no one probably wants to accept is that these are going to continue a limited, random-type pace and there really isn't any law, action or otherwise that's going to change it. And if they actually pass some of these things -- whether it's arm teaches or ban AR15s, they'll still happen and the reaction won't be, "welp, maybe we can't do much about them" -- the reaction will be "we didn't arm and train the teachers well enough! or we didn't ban enough guns!
What we are going to get in the short-term is poorly thought out feel good fixes. I think you and those on the realistic side of issues with regard to the legislative process (i.e., it's a slog at the Federal and State levels) recognize that any kind of ban on even well circumscribed firearms isn't going to happen.
The gun culture in the US has to change just as the tobacco/smoking culture did. Unfortunately, that may be as big of a pie in the sky thing as changing the law is.
My view, though is that we need to resist the tendency to shrug shoulders. Reasonable dialogue is possible as we've seen here from both sides. I'd think the best place to start is "nibbling" (your term) around the edges of the 2A as has been done with 1A. Where would you suggest such an undertaking begin?Mission to CFB's National Championship accomplished. But the shine on the NC Trophy is embarrassingly wearing off. It's M B-Ball ..... or hockey or volley ball or name your college sport favorite time ...... until next year.
- Top
Comment
-
Originally posted by iam416 View PostGreat find, AA. There are better scenes, but watching that scene was the first time I knew I was watching greatness.
Yes. The show, all around, was so good. It can spoil you, though. You keep hoping for that next Wire level show. And while HBO does a great job with its series, everything else falls a bit short.
AA's ranking of HBO shows:
1. The Wire
2. Sopranos
3. Game of Thrones
4. Deadwood
5. Boardwalk Empire
6. Rome
7. Curb Your Enthusiasm
8. Treme"The problem with quotes on the Internet is that it is sometimes hard to verify their authenticity." -Abraham Lincoln
- Top
Comment
-
Reasonable dialogue is possible as we've seen here from both sides
Where would you suggest such an undertaking begin?
So, apply it to gun laws. First, we have basic background checks for felons. That's good. Second, implement layered background checks depending on the type of gun you're purchasing. If you want to purchase a handgun (semi-automatic or not), it's a standard background check. If you want to purchase a semi-automatic rifle, then it's a more advanced background check + waiting period. Third, for semi-automatic rifles you can also think about licenses. Fourth, I love David French's "Gun Violence Restraining Order" idea. Fifth, I would consider a "gun license" program. If you want to buy any gun you need to take and pass a gun ownership course -- it doesn't have to long -- it can be a couple hours or something. If you pass and have a "gun license" then you can bypass the more severe semi-automatic rifle background check.
So, the point of all these is to put marginal "pain in the ass" hurdles up that people who want to own guns (and aren't felons) can pass, but there has to be a commitment. It also avoids the word "ban" -- I really think that's a political loser. Now, some of my suggestions may be losers, too, but they offer a legislative path that, IMO, won't require 60 Senate votes to pass. So, if the Ds win Congress and the Presidency as I think they will in 2020, they have a course they can take.
Now, the Ds won't take it because it's a compromise position. They'll try to ban "assault weapons" knowing the Rs won't agree and make it a political issue.Dan Patrick: What was your reaction to [Urban Meyer being hired]?
Brady Hoke: You know.....not....good.
- Top
Comment
-
Also, those are just my suggestions, but that's how I'd think about it if I were Ds. In fact, I would start putting those types of regulations in place in blue states. That's what the Rs do with abortion. It's a state issue. And if you're not denying access but merely requiring various things for access, you'll survive Constitutional scrutiny.
The other thing that I think is important to note is enforcement. I've said it before and I'll say it again -- *if* we ramp up enforcement it's going to have the same disparate effect on AAs that the war on drugs has. IF you're concerned with the industrial prison complex then massive, unflinching gun law enforcement is something that you ought to at least have serious reservations about. I'm not overly concerned with it and I definitely have reservations about putting lots of people in jail for possessing a gun illegally. Yet, man, if you're going to pass the laws you gotsta enforce them, right?
My exception for enforcement are straw purchases. 10 years is too much, but jail time is appropriate.Dan Patrick: What was your reaction to [Urban Meyer being hired]?
Brady Hoke: You know.....not....good.
- Top
Comment
-
Originally posted by Dr. Strangelove View PostJust researched it. Alabama's drinkin age was raised to 21 in 1933 with the end of Prohibition.
Damn, AA....or should I call you...Old Scribe?????
One of my friend's sons joined the USMC after a bad year at college. He came home from Afghanistan on leave once and a big group of us were watching a game at BWW and he couldn't buy a beer because he hadn't reached 21 yet (he was fairly close - a few months, iirc). It just struck me as fucking ridiculous that his dad had to buy him a beer and act like it was his when the waitress came by.
Or that, two 18-year-olds can get married against their parent's wishes, move out, have a couple of babies, but not buy a Miller Lite.
Does that age group handle booze well? Probably not, but if I produced a study that showed that blacks -statistically- were much worse with alcohol-related issues, would we be okay with restricting their access to alcohol differently than we do with whites?"The problem with quotes on the Internet is that it is sometimes hard to verify their authenticity." -Abraham Lincoln
- Top
Comment
-
band of brothers 2
GOT 3
sopranos 6
VEEP 7
all you golf junkies--8 of us just got back from scottsdale
4 nights/5 days in a nice condo full kitchen 3 tvs balcony off tatum and 101across street from desert ridge market place--highly recommend keg steakhouse
130 holes of golf including kierland/biltmore/lookout mountain/legacy/ and estrella
860 bucks apiece
- Top
Comment
-
Originally posted by iam416 View PostArming teachers is just silly.
At the schools where they have an actual real, legitimate threat of gun violence, they have metal detectors and guards. That's quite the expenditure, but for some schools the threat is real enough to make it worthwhile.
Seeing as how you're not taking 300 million guns out of circulation nor stopping criminals from getting guns (a War on Guns! would go about as well as our War on Drugs!), if you really want to stop school shootings this would an effective approach, at least of areas inside the school.
That said, the shooters can still wait outside. Or go to other public places.
The reality that no one probably wants to accept is that these are going to continue a limited, random-type pace and there really isn't any law, action or otherwise that's going to change it. And if they actually pass some of these things -- whether it's arm teaches or ban AR15s, they'll still happen and the reaction won't be, "welp, maybe we can't do much about them" -- the reaction will be "we didn't arm and train the teachers well enough! or we didn't ban enough guns!
You are also correct that the shootings will continue no matter what. But we can try to slow them, or stop more of them. That?s the whole point.To be a professional means that you don't die. - Takeru "the Tsunami" Kobayashi
- Top
Comment
-
For the fuck of it I'll start thinking about my favorite scenes from The Wire. This one is certainly in the top 10, probably top 5:
[ame="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cW-iQNwNshQ"]Snoop from The Wire's Grand Entrance - YouTube[/ame]Dan Patrick: What was your reaction to [Urban Meyer being hired]?
Brady Hoke: You know.....not....good.
- Top
Comment
-
You are also correct that the shootings will continue no matter what. But we can try to slow them, or stop more of them. That’s the whole point.Dan Patrick: What was your reaction to [Urban Meyer being hired]?
Brady Hoke: You know.....not....good.
- Top
Comment
-
Originally posted by crashcourse View Postband of brothers 2
GOT 3
sopranos 6
VEEP 7
all you golf junkies--8 of us just got back from scottsdale
4 nights/5 days in a nice condo full kitchen 3 tvs balcony off tatum and 101across street from desert ridge market place--highly recommend keg steakhouse
130 holes of golf including kierland/biltmore/lookout mountain/legacy/ and estrella
860 bucks apiece
The Scottsdale trip sounds good. What company did you book with?"The problem with quotes on the Internet is that it is sometimes hard to verify their authenticity." -Abraham Lincoln
- Top
Comment
Comment